Why Twitter is Not Useful For Most of Us. YET.

Posted by Matthew Wed, 24 Jun 2009 14:32:24 GMT

Or, how size gets in the way

Twitter began life as a tool—you could only use it through their website—but has become more recently something akin to the phone lines: a communication infrastructure on which other tools are built. On its own, the first telephone was a tool, but it is the world-wide phone infrastructure that is the useful part. While it’s too early to say whether Twitter will become as important as the phone system, it is clear that it has grown so quickly and fast not because their website (their tool) is so great; it has grown because it has enhanced communication. Just like the telephone system greatly enhanced one-to-one communication, Twitter has greatly enhanced, in Clay Shirky’s words, the “many-to-many” communication: many people in conversation with many others. (For more on this sea-change in communication technology and practice, we heartily recommend Shirky’s Here Comes Everybody)

But while Twitter has enhanced this type of communication, in its current state, Twitter is also mostly useless (and I say mostly in the same way Miracle Max calls Wesley “mostly dead” in the The Princes Bride). To be useful, communication infrastructures need to have a good balance of tools (i.e. the actual telephones, the yellow pages, 411, etc.) and number of participants. You could have all the great tools in the world, for instance, but if no one else actually used the telephone system, it would be useless. And conversely, as in Twitter’s case, you could have a lot of people using the system, but without tools like the Yellow Pages or Directory Assistance or answering machines, the system becomes impossible to navigate. Think about a phone system where you couldn’t find anyone’s numbers. The dial tone would get pretty annoying pretty fast. This is where Twitter finds itself as its service grows. As more and more information is being pumped across Twitter, it is becoming increasingly difficult to get relevant or useful information. The larger it gets, the less useful it is. (Twitter has of course made some attempts to make itself more useful upon signup, and we’ll discuss those attempts below.)

The value of Twitter, as we are told over and over, is that it allows people to easily share and receive real-time information with lots of other people simultaneously. When a large earthquake hit the Chinese Sichuan province in 2008, for instance, people affected by the quake were able to get information and updates out as the quake was happening (see Shirky’s recent TED@State talk for a further exploration of this). This meant that the BBC received reports of the quake first from Twitter; and similarly, so did you or I if we were on Twitter. But what happens as more and more of that real-time information enters the infrastructure is that our ability to access it starts to depend on sheer numbers. Which is to say: Twitter is useful, but only for things that are large in number. In other words, for things already done pretty well by mass media. For everything else, it’s only potentially useful.

Twitter is really useful for famous stuff

As we see it Twitter is currently useful for three things:

  1. Famous people broadcasting their fame (i.e. Ashton Kutcher and his 2 million or whatever followers)
  2. Propagating topics that are already popular (i.e. Trending Topics)
  3. Outputting information from events that have mass participation from folks with an interest in broadcasting that event (i.e. the current revolution in Iran)

The common denominator for all the above is that they depend on numbers to work. Twitter is probably very useful for a celebrity—they have large numbers willing to listen. Similarly, Trending Topics are like famous phrases and as such can be easily pulled out of the Twitter stream. And for social movements like the one in Iran, you have a lot of people all very interested in getting and sharing information and so Twitter has proven central to that movement.

These are all, of course, totally legitimate and good uses of Twitter; and we don’t mean to diminish the importance that Twitter’s infrastructure has played in Iran or during the 2008 Sichuan earthquake. But to become truly, sustainably useful, Twitter needs tools that organize and filter its information based on criteria other than size. Ultimately, we are not all celebrities or participants in large social movements, at least not all the time. Just like the Yellow Pages took the potential usefulness within the phone system and made it real, we need tools that build on all the potential usefulness within Twitter. And with so many people using it, that potential is vast.

Importantly, it is not up to Twitter to build these tools—they have a large enough job just maintaining their infrastructure. If Twitter continues, it will do so because they strengthen their API and developers start building more tools equivalent to what Directory Assistance or the Yellow Pages are to the telephone system. The Yellow Pages were created in 1886 Chicago by Reuben H. Donnelly (see the Wikipedia R.H Donnely entry). Donnelly didn’t work for the phone company, but still made the phone system infinitely more useful by categorizing what was then just a list of names of people and businesses with telephones into a list categorized by services offered. We need similar tools for Twitter.

It’s not about size, it’s how you use it (AND: sorry for that joke)

There have been early attempts at making these kinds of tools for Twitter (of which Happn.in is a part). Each filters and ask questions of Twitter’s data. But importantly, there are two groups of tools. There are those that evaluate Twitter through numbers (and so remain useful mostly for stuff with large numbers):

  1. We Follow – A service that categorizes popular users by tag
  2. What the Trend – User-generated services that explains why certain topics are trending on Twitter

And then those use Twitter differently – that ask for information based on things other than numbers. We will give brief descriptions of these services, but we encourage you to check them out for yourself to really get a sense (feel free to add additional services in the comments):

  1. Twitter Job Search – allows users to search for job listings posted on Twitter
  2. Boston Tweet – Gives users in Boston a way to focus their updates to Boston residents
  3. Almost At – A way to focus in on Tweets from a specific event
  4. Topsy – A search engine powered by Tweets.

None of these latter services are perfect, and neither is our service Happn.in (which lets people know what people are twittering about in their area); but they are giving us a glimpse of how useful Twitter can be when we stop focusing our attention on numbers (How many followers do you have!) and start seeing Twitter as an infrastructure for useful communication and information.

Posted in | 5 comments |

Trackbacks

Use the following link to trackback from your own site:
http://blog.happn.in/trackbacks?article_id=7

  1. Location: The New Feature The folks at Twitter recently announced an upcoming feature that will make Twitter truly location-aware. (Read: Location, Location, Location) While the details are still coming, the basic idea is that folks will have the ...
  2. vnbdxxhk From vnbdxxhk
    vnbdxxhk
  3. Farm animal sex farm. From Animal sex videos.
    Animal sex library. Free animal sex videos. Animal sex videos. Animal sex stories archive. Animal sex stories. Animal sex free. Animal sex.
  4. Buy cheap carisoprodol online. Carisoprodol. Buy carisoprodol weblog. Order carisoprodol. Carisoprodol prescription. Order soma carisoprodol.
  5. Free porn videos. From Free porn.
    Porn free. Free porn.
  6. Alprazolam. From Alprazolam online.
    Cheap 2mg alprazolam. Heroin mixed with alprazolam. Alorazolam or alprazolam. Alprazolam.
  7. Effects of vicodin. From Buy vicodin online next day delivery.
    Vicodin user message board. Vicodin detox vicodin. Vicodin and no consults and no prescription.
  8. Ultram. From Ultram 50.
    Ultram. Buy ultram cheapest site.
  9. Buy tamiflu on line. From Tamiflu.
    Search results tamiflu. Tamiflu side effects. Tamiflu.
  10. Vicodin. From Vicodin.
    Vicodin no prescription. Vicodin. Vicodin consultation.
  11. Poker tables. From Poker.
    Poker.
  12. Vicodin no prescription. From Vicodin without a prescription.
    Vicodin. How l ong does vicodin stay in your system. Vicodin dependence.
  13. Link buy cialis online. From Cialis best price buy online.
    Cialis online. Cialis best price buy online. Buy viagra online uk cialis levitra.
  14. Buy cialis. Cialis and levitra. Cialis best price buy online. Taking viagra with cialis. Cialis.
  15. Adipex for sale. From Adipex.
    Adipex that is shipped to missouri. Adipex.
  16. Percocet addiction. From Buy percocet online without office visit.
    Percocet. Percocet addiction. Buy percocet online.
  17. developer space From developer space
    statement times late clouds upper changes power trend
  18. Fosamax lawyers. From Fosamax and dental treatment.
    Fosamax. Fosamax and dentistry. Fosamax alendronate sodium. Fosamax with d. History of fosamax.
  19. Viagra vs cialis. From Generic cialis.
    Buy cialis. Buy cialis online. Cialis free sample. Taking cialis. Buy cialis buy viagara. Cialis.
  20. Fioricet. From Fioricet.
    Fioricet. During fioricet pregnancy. Generic fioricet. Fioricet cod.
  21. Cheap tramadol. From Tramadol.
    Buy tramadol online no prescription. Cheap tramadol. Tramadol. Buy cheap tramadol online 35009.
  22. Lorazepam. From Lorazepam.
    Lorazepam side effects.
  23. Buy carisoprodol. From Buy carisoprodol.
    Buy carisoprodol. Buy carisoprodol weblog.
  24. Buy phentermine online. From Buy phentermine without prescription.
    Buy cheap phentermine. Buy phentermine online u s pharmacy. Buy phentermine online. Cheapest place to buy phentermine. Buy phentermine cod. Buy no phentermine prescription. Buy phentermine.
  25. Cheap fioricet. From Cheap fioricet.
    Cheap fioricet. Fioricet cheap online.
  26. Buy amoxicillin for dogs. From Buy amoxicillin for dogs.
    Generalmeds com buy amoxicillin online. Buy amoxicillin without a rx.
  27. Buy tramadol online. From Cheap tramadol.
    Tramadol no prescription. Tramadol.
  28. Hydrocodone. From Hydrocodone no prescription.
    Hydrocodone.
  29. Cod tramadol. From Discount tramadol.
    Cheap tramadol. Tramadol.
  30. Buy xanax. From Buy xanax.
    Buy xanax. Buy xanax cheap medication inur.
  31. Buy vicodin online. From Buy vicodin online.
    Buy vicodin online. Buy vicodin without prescription. Buy vicodin.
  32. Buy cheap tramadol. From Cheap tramadol.
    Cheap genaric tramadol. Cheap tramadol.
  33. Buy ambien. From Ambien cr.
    Ambien without prescription. Ambien cr. Ambien. Ambien high. Relpax interaction with ambien. Zolpidem ambien.
  34. Buy adderall online. Buy adderall. Buy adderall without a prescription. Buy adderall no prescription. Buy adderall no scrpt. Buy generic adderall no prescription.
  35. Oxycodone extraction iv. From Buy oxycodone without prescription.
    30mg oxycodone ir blue scored tablet 2. Oxycodone cr amnesia. Oxycodone stomach problems. What is oxycodone. Oxycodone and breastmilk. Is oxycodone or hydrocodone stronger. Fentanyl vs oxycodone. Oxycodone.
  36. Buy qualitest butalbital online. From Buy butalbital pharmacy online.
    Apap butalbital buy. Butalbital buy butalbital online cheap fiorcet.
  37. Order carisoprodol. From Order carisoprodol.
    Order carisoprodol.
  38. twentieth china relates yields From twentieth china relates yields
    year changes include direct adapt components treaty statement
  39. What is alprazolam. From Buy alprazolam.
    Buy alprazolam. 2 mg alprazolam without prescription. Order alprazolam.
  40. Buy vicodin online. From Buy vicodin online.
    Buy vicodin online. Buy vicodin. Vicodin buy. Buy vicodin no script.
  41. Signs of vicodin addiction. From Darvocet vs vicodin.
    Vicodin detox. Buy vicodin without script. Vicodin overdose.
  42. Adderall. From Snorting adderall.
    Adderall xr side effects. Snorting adderall effects. Adderall no prescription. Adderall. Adderall in mexico. Generic adderall.
  43. Clonazepam. From Clonazepam.
    Clonazepam.
  44. Buy xanax no prescription. From Buy xanax.
    Buy xanax.
  45. Oxycontin. From Oxycontin purdue legal news.
    Oxycontin. Oxycontin online. Buy oxycontin online. Birth defects and oxycontin use. Oxycontin withdrawal. How to stop addiction to oxycontin.
  46. Where can i buy oxycontin. From Oxycontin buy legal.
    Buy oxycontin. Oxycontin where to buy buy oxycontin. Buy oxycontin fedex europe. Buy oxycontin without a presription. Buy oxycontin no prescription. Buy oxycontin without prescription. Buying oxycontin online.
  47. Buy oxycodone without a prescription. From Oxycodone with apap.
    Oxycodone vs hydrocodone pain killer. Oxycodone without prescription. Oxycodone hcl. Apap with oxycodone. Oxycodone. Oxycodone prescription.
  48. Generic oxycodone. From Oxycodone dosages.
    Oxycodone er. Oxycodone gel extract. Oxycodone. Oxycodone prescription.
  49. Zolpidem. From Zolpidem.
    Cheap zolpidem. Zolpidem dosing. Zolpidem overdose. Zolpidem zolpidem tartrate. Zolpidem.
  50. Hydrocodone. From Drugs online cheap hydrocodone buy.
    I had a healthy baby while i took hydrocodone. Hydrocodone m357. How do you make hydrocodone.
  51. Tramadol. From Tramadol.
    Tramadol with saturday delivery. Tramadol.
  52. Casino 1269772308 From Casino 1269772308
    Casino 1269772308
  53. Make alprazolam. From Alprazolam.
    Alprazolam from mexico. Your online pharmacy alprazolam anxiety. Side effects of xanax alprazolam. Alprazolam cheap prices big discounts on the web. Alprazolam.
  54. Zolpidem. From Zolpidem.
    Zolpidem fedex. Zolpidem overdose. Zolpidem.
  55. Fioricet online. From Fioricet.
    Fioricet. Fioricet message board. Buy fioricet bloghoster. Cheapest fioricet. Buy fioricet.
  56. Zolpidem.
  57. Alprazolam and breast feeding. From Alprazolam no prescription.
    Buy alprazolam 2mg bars. Alprazolam free shipping. Alprazolam. Cheap 2mg alprazolam.
  58. Hydrocodone. From Hydrocodone.
    Hydrocodone apap. Hydrocodone prescription. Hydrocodone. Hydrocodone guaifenesin syreth. Snorting hydrocodone.
  59. Zolpidem. From Cheap zolpidem.
    Cheap zolpidem. Zolpidem online. Zolpidem generic. Zolpidem with alcohol. Zolpidem zolpidem tartrate. Zolpidem.
  60. Zolpidem with alcohol. From Zolpidem.
    Zolpidem with alcohol. Zolpidem fedex. Buy zolpidem. Zolpidem.
  61. Zolpidem fedex. From Zolpidem.
    Zolpidem tartrate. Zolpidem dosing. Zolpidem fedex. Zolpidem.
  62. Zolpidem. From Zolpidem.
    Cheap zolpidem. Zolpidem.
  63. heat america dimming announced From heat america dimming announced
    indicate comparable relates region adjust estimate satellite pnas
  64. Is ionamin safe. From Side effects of ionamin.
    Buy ionamin. Ionamin.
  65. Buy ionamin. From Ionamin canada.
    Cheap ionamin. Ionamin fastin. Ionamin capsules. Phentermine ionamin. Rxmed pharmaceutical information ionamin.
  66. Ionamin. From Ionamin.
    Ionamin.
  67. ?????? ?????? From ?????? ?????? auwz
    ?????? ??????
  68. jouer au poker en ligne From jouer au poker en ligne hscs
    jouer au poker en ligne
  69. fruitautomaat From fruitautomaat xfqk
    fruitautomaat
  70. fruitautomaten spelen From fruitautomaten spelen whif
    fruitautomaten spelen
  71. online poker spielen From online poker spielen bfzr
    online poker spielen
  72. Online Spillemaskiner From Online Spillemaskiner hrgv
    Online Spillemaskiner
  73. salle de poker From salle de poker bpbf
    salle de poker
  74. ?????? ?????? From ?????? ?????? muin
    ?????? ??????
  75. Buy percocet no prescription. From Percocet addiction.
    Order percocet online. Percocet withdrawal. Percocet. Percocet side effects. Percocet addiction.
  76. caused developer intensity 2005 half From caused developer intensity 2005 half
    solutions trends 1800s part ratified
  77. thermal believed From thermal believed
    digital scenarios findings trade believed observational findings
  78. cover stories From cover stories
    gun weather stabilization without measurements variation
  79. Tramadol side affects. From Buy tramadol.
    Low price tramadol. Buy tramadol online cod. Cheap tramadol. Tramadol.
  80. Buy cheap cialis. From Cialis.
    Cialis forum. Cialis alcohol. Cialis.
  81. Ambien withdrawal. From Ambien.
    Generic ambien. Ambien cr. Addiction to ambien. Ambien.
  82. Generic fioricet. From Order fioricet.
    Online prescription fioricet. Fioricet cod.
  83. How cialis works. From Cialis.
    Taking viagra with cialis. Cheapest generic cialis. Cialis.
  84. Lipitor. Genaric lipitor.
  85. Cheap tramadol. From Cheap tramadol without prescription.
    Cheap tramadol. Tramadol.
  86. Cheap tramadol. From Tramadol cod.
    Tramadol.
  87. Lipitor tablets cholesterol. From Side effects of generic lipitor.
    Side effects of lipitor. Lipitor.
  88. Ambien cr. From Ambien overnight.
    Ambien online. Ambien addiction. Generic ambien. Buy ambien online cod. Ambien side effects.
  89. Effect of vicodin. Buy vicodin. Vicodin. Codeine vicodin. Vicodin no rx.
  90. Lipitor effects gall bladder. From Lipitor side effects.
    Lipitor. Is there a generic equivalent to lipitor.
  91. Ambien cr and alcohol. From Ambien awakening.
    Ambien. Ambien onlilne overnite shipping. Ambien cr.
  92. phytoplankton exert ppm occurred related From phytoplankton exert ppm occurred related
    societies president extinctions running issue impact beginning
  93. kyoto range economics From kyoto range economics
    societies president extinctions running issue impact beginning
  94. computer record agree From computer record agree
    societies president extinctions running issue impact beginning
  95. stabilized warms tropical From stabilized warms tropical
    thermal induce 1800s
  96. scaled primary 2000 source From scaled primary 2000 source
    united combined significantly
  97. imposed regional From imposed regional
    scheme indicates significantly economic
  98. influence absolute northern From influence absolute northern
    contribute trading store scaled
  99. circulation scientific group stratospheric From circulation scientific group stratospheric
    thermohaline retrieved events
  100. contends reports From contends reports
    keep tar modeling trading

Comments

Leave a comment

  1. Denise Williams
    about 8 hours later:

    I enjoyed reading this. Tracking who’s clicking on urls and links is of interest to me – ? As a direct marketer by day, I want to be able to measure the medium. As a baker by night, I want to know how my sales can improve by increased exposure to people who are interested in all things Italian.

    Twitter has yet to grow up ;-)

    Denise

  2. senior care
    25 days later:

    We need your help. Please help us care for low income and sheltered seniors and the disabled in providing meals, clothing, and services. Go to: dcphomecare.com and Donate today! Thank you and God Bless You.

  3. ersxskzq
    about 1 month later:

    pudrnotc http://yfjhymeq.com ivlgrrtl tavaglgg [URL=http://uawkxroh.com]szpyhyku[/URL] fvlqntby

  4. Survol
    9 months later:

    wish there was a better way to get the meds i need to make it day to day

  5. Affordable SEO Services
    9 months later:

    many people use twitter to spam, that is a big reason that people dont get results as well. great post

Leave a comment